Black Sitcom, Jewish Writers

I could spend time waxing poetic about MLK Jr. marching alongside rabbis and the Jews who pushed for civil rights through the ACLU and other orgs, helping Black Americans secure rights they should have had a century earlier. The Black-Jewish alliance is well known to anyone who looks for it, and despised by those who hate either group.

But, truthfully, TV from 1960s-2010s influenced me more than anything else, including civil rights activists.

Besides, I’m just finishing my rewatch of Scrubs, where Jewish actor Zach Braff and Black actor Donald Faison reproduce their real-life friendship, arguably the central point of the show and the reason it did so well. And as I ponder what to watch next, a list of “Black TV shows” with Jewish producers and/or mostly Jewish writers came to mind, each of which I loved watching an occasional episode of, but never got to binge because I was born decades too late. Mainly:

  1. Sanford and Son: Redd Foxx with Jewish writer-producers Saul Turteltaub and Bernie Orenstein.

  2. The Jeffersons: Black cast, with Jewish producer Norman Lear and writer-producer Bernie West.

  3. Good Times: Black cast, produced by Norman Lear, though co-created by Black writers Eric Monte and Mike Evans.

  4. What's Happening!!: Black cast, with Jewish producers Turteltaub and Orenstein.

  5. The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air: Will Smith, with Jewish co-creator Andy Borowitz.


Today we’re talking about these shows in particular, with some added less relevant mentions cause that’s just me. I like asides, like mentioning that Mel Brooks gave Dave Chappelle one of his earliest film roles, only for Chappelle to go on to contribute to antisemitism and clapter comedy, backstabbing the Jews who helped him launch.

TV brought Black families, Black neighborhoods, Black humor, and Black stars into American living rooms every single week, in decades when racial tensions were high. It normalized people whom much of the country was still not particularly interested in seeing as their neighbors. And whether this facet is appreciated or labeled “Jewish/Zio usurping” and “culture stealing,” much of that television was written, produced, or developed by Jews.

I am confident that if I asked you to think of classic Black sitcoms, one of the five I listed above would come up first.

Two minority groups worked through the entertainment industry in their own ways and influenced each other’s futures for the better. I think it’s beautiful. Others don’t, and we’ll get to that next.

Chronologically speaking, we have to start with Sanford and Son. Redd Foxx was the star, the reason the show worked. But the writing on the show was overseen by Jewish writer-producers Saul Turteltaub and Bernie Orenstein. The show was also developed within the broader Norman Lear orbit, whose imprint on American television was enormous. It was one of the first Black sitcoms to become a national hit, and it helped establish the idea that a Black family-centered comedy could anchor network television. (Television Academy; Jewish Journal)

Then came Good Times, again produced by Norman Lear, but importantly, co-created by Black writers Eric Monte and Mike Evans. The Jeffersons also came out of the Lear empire. Jewish executives were partnering with Black Americans to get their stories out in a more authentic way. They collaborated. Certainly, there were disputes, like in any other collaboration, but with Good Times and the other shows, Black and Jewish collaborators publicly gave constant praise for one another.

What’s Happening!! was produced by Turteltaub and Orenstein. Later on, The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air was co-created by Andy Borowitz, a Jewish comedy writer who has openly acknowledged that, in a different television era, the expectation would probably be different. That alone tells you how much the norms have changed. (WBEZ interview with Andy Borowitz)


Immediately, there were haters, complaining that Jewish writers were mediating Blackness for mass consumption. That criticism was not invented by the Twitter Nazis and Reddit Marxists who insist that the “Zios are stealing cultures” and usurping them. In a 1973 New York Times critique cited by the Television Academy, Black writer Eugenia Collier reportedly called Sanford and Son “white to the core.” That brutal line is echoed in later shows that ask what it means to be Black. (Television Academy)

A slept-on cartoon, The Cleveland Show, and the more famous sitcom 30 Rock, mocked its own Black and Jewish writers’ room dynamic and regularly criticized this idea of “white to core, Black men.” The all-Black writers' room behind Atlanta also criticized the concept of “Oreos,” or people who are Black on the outside but white on the inside, albeit from an all black writers’ room. [Note, as a white Jew, my thoughts on how identity and personality are inseparable, but calling certain common traits “white” or “Black” is deeply racist, is trivial.]

Mel Watkins’s 1979 essay, Writing in Black and White, is more relevant to understanding this history. Watkins was writing while these debates were still alive, before influence by blindly repeated social media PC-isms. He interviewed Black and white television professionals about who was writing Black comedy, how Jewish comedy traditions shaped television, and whether Black performers were being asked to fit themselves into someone else’s comic structure. One of the points raised in the piece is that television comedy had inherited the rhythms of Jewish comedy, especially the Borscht Belt style of setup, punchline, timing, and verbal exchange. This invited resentment. Since TV was heavily shaped by Jewish humor, then Black performers succeeding within that system could look, to critics, less like representation and more like translation.

Again, not that my opinion here matters, but I think most comedians (especially those I’ve heard on the We Might Be Drunk podcast) see both representation and translation. Black stand-up, especially roast battles, can be far more personal, degrading, and harsh than the family-friendly comedy in sitcoms. There is still mas crossover between Black and Jewish culture (or Jewish and Italian culture). And nuance to culture. All can be true.

The line between collaboration and usurpation is one people still fight over. Some see Jewish involvement in Black entertainment as solidarity, mentorship, and shared outsider status. Others see it as Jews profiting from another culture. Such criticisms are not limited to television, but extend to music, especially hip-hop. Gatekeeping and authorship arguments have led to claims of “Jews stealing everything” and the revival of millennia-old antisemitic reflexes.

There is a selective hypocrisy here. Some Jews who entered Black musical spaces were treated as having crossed some forbidden line. The Beastie Boys and Lil Dicky were not supposed to do their take on hip-hop (while Jewish Wu-Tang affiliate Remedy was largely overlooked). And yet, today in 2026, Irish artists are borrowing Black styles, Black slang, Black politics and Black aesthetics in far more opportunistic and cartoonish ways, without comparable New York Times commentary. There doesn't seem to be the same cultural-appropriation panic when artists like Macklemore and Kneecrap—whom I consider deeply antisemitic charlatans—not only borrow from a culture but make the absolute worst version of it, focusing on performance and social media trends over creativity, substance and art.

To me, the Black-Jewish alliance is a real creative partnership. Jewish and Black artists did not just orbit one another abstractly; they built things together. Even outside sitcoms, television helped move the culture. Star Trek gave America the famous kiss between William Shatner and Nichelle Nichols, one of the earliest scripted interracial kisses on American television. Jews helped normalize interracial couples, business partnerships, and more, and of course were heavily criticized for it.


Writing all this may seem ironic, because I have railed so strongly against excessive identity politics. But those rants and raves were never a statement against ethnic sitcoms. Ethnic sitcoms are fantastic. I love to hear that the Taliban watches Seinfeld!

People sometimes need a break from the Real Housewives and Kardashians, whose lives they will never live, to see something more familiar: The Goldbergs, black-ish, Fresh Off the Boat. By the way, while black-ish was created by Kenya Barris and staffed in a much more self-consciously Black creative environment, it was typically paired with The Goldbergs, with good reason.

Whether people like it or not, the fact remains that the door to all-Black shows was opened through collaborations with Jews. Black and Jewish Americans collaborated in one of the most powerful mediums of the modern age. Together they helped America learn to live with itself. I wish to see more collaboration, more J.D.-Turk friendships, and fewer homogeneous credits.


Next
Next

The Founding Zios Wanted Arabs to Vote... and To Lead Israel