Anna hasn’t been dating. And as a voluntary non-dater, her supply of Seinfeldian judgments over trivial things is dwindling.
As my wise Hungarian friend said, “I am not a ruler over all icks.” Since I want to keep this series going for a few more posts, I’ve continued polling friends for their icks. Most of these come from Meredith.
You either get the ick or die an icker.
For Volume 1: Anna's Icks Vol. 1
For Volume 2: Anna's Icks Vol. 2
19. Saying “Shalommmm” or “Helloooo” during foreplay/intercourse
Imagine: You’re getting intimate with someone. They take your pants off. Then they say “Shalommmm” (“Hellooooooo”) in an exaggerated, surprised tone.
This true encounter haunted me for days. Really.
This wasn’t someone’s soon-to-be “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” learning about an above-average penis size. A girl reported it to my ick hotline. A straight man made it all the way to her black underwear (10 Things I Hate About You), let out a very flamboyant response, and destroyed the mood.
Upon hearing this, my thought was, “Surely, this doesn’t happen often.” Then the stories came out. Some liked it, some hurled. Anna, our titular ick-haver-er, said this was a perfectly normal first-time-in-bed move. She then responded, “Meowwwww,” in a catty tone. I cried a bit.
People who really enjoyed Friends are OK with this
20. Dainty (coffee/tea) drinking habits
Once again proving I know absolutely nothing about women, this one was agreed upon more than #19. I’d have guessed there was some leeway for a man who likes sugary coffee, maybe even boba tea. Nope. “Coffee - black.”
This ick started with, “They stir their coffee with a little spoon.” Then, “They drink from a bottle with no more liquid in it.” Soon, all the icky drinking habits came out, and it became apparent that coffee with three+ sugars is a bigger turnoff than a cheap cigarette or owning a pet snake.
My immediate question was, “How’s a man supposed to stir his coffee or tea if little spoons are forbidden? A Swiss Army knife? Twigs and sticks? What is the manly way?”
And while sticks are strangely more acceptable in the niche world of picky daters, Meredith insisted that men shouldn’t stir drinks at all. Others were concerned with the daintiness of the act, not the stirring itself, as if there’s a sloshy, OK method.
Basically, men get to put one sugar in their drinks. It just has to stay heterogeneous. The sugar has to sit at the bottom, making a sludge dessert for the last few sips.
Anna, who is shockingly OK with men stirring their coffee, later confessed, “When they hold up their little finger. Like, who are you, the Queen of England?” That’s why I’m painting the title with a broad stroke.
If you’re going to stir, just do it brutally, with liquid sloshing over the sides, not caring. Then chug it all. “Drink like a man.” Or throw the coffee at a prettier girl, tell her she’s not as hot as your date, then shotgun a beer. Boys! Boys! Boys!
21. Jumping over a puddle
There was a time when it was considered romantic for a man to cover a puddle with his jacket. Yep, destroy your most expensive piece of clothing so that a lady doesn’t get her shoes wet. And since this old-timey trick doesn’t work today, consider destroying your jacket to symbolize your masculine energy and deep hatred for wet socks.
Those times are long gone. We’ve moved on to, “Well, damn, Jackie. I can’t control the weather.”
Apparently, men jumping over puddles is also ick. You’re supposed to just get your shoes wet or, idk, crazy thought, go around the puddle? A few friends signed off on this one, with one clarifying, “I get it if it’s a first date.”
I don’t get it. At all.
Note: According to some guy writing for MEL Magazine in 2022, the jacket-over-a-puddle thing is an ick. He tried it on his wife, who refused to walk over it. The article ultimately suggests “carrying yourself and your companion over it.” Now I wouldn’t pick someone up on a first date unless they asked very nicely, nor take advice from MEL Magazine. But that’s just me. Feel free to read MEL Magazine, which I am not familiar with!
Parkour!
22. Running to jaywalk or catch a green pedestrian light
Sticking with pedestrian icks, most women would rather wait for the next light than watch a man do that awkward little run across the street. Even worse if he’s sprinting to beat oncoming traffic like a human Frogger.
I guess some girls would rather just wait and be safe. I can respect that. But I also don't want to stand around for another two minutes when I can make the light. Instead, I’ll stare at you from across the way, judgingly.
23. Aggressively responding “I know!” to safety warnings
Someone says, “Don’t cross, there are cars coming,” and gets an angry “I KNOW!” in response.
Look, I did this in the past. I’m not proud of it, but I’ve grown. It’s a safety check. Pilots do it all the time. There’s nothing wrong with someone looking out for you, even if you already saw the danger. They don’t want you to get hit by a car FFS.
Train yourself to say, “Thanks, I saw,” or something genuinely appreciative sounding, even if your knee-jerk reaction is to get defensive.
24. Stuffing snotty tissues into the toilet-paper roll
Side note: I really think I’m living in a parallel simulation to my previous one, because I swear I mentioned this before. But I can’t find it. This may be my third time mentioning such a “who cares” aside on my blog, but whatevs. Here it is.
Israelis have a disgusting habit of using toilet paper as tissue paper (OK so far), then jamming the used paper into the cardboard tube in the middle of the roll whence thine toilet paper came from. Yes, there's still meat on the bone! They just keep stuffing more snotty paper in there as they use the roll.
This is shockingly common, especially among elders who don’t seem to care how disgusting it is.
I will say it's by far the ickiest thing I would include on my own list. When someone else mentioned it, I was happy to add it here.
25. Worshipping celebs
The only people who matter are the ones in your extended friend group, people you might actually interact with. We’re building a world where increasingly irrelevant people, especially social-media algorithm beaters who aren’t even artistic or intelligent, are destroying us. We're forced to learn the latest drama about people nobody should care about. It's weird.
To clarify, liking celebrities isn't the ick. It's obsessively following their personal lives, defending them like they're family, and getting genuinely upset over their feuds. It doesn’t matter if they do it over Elon Musk or Gretta, just stop.
Now, I know, I know, I’m rambling about the non-artists. And maybe you love Kanye West or Josh Gad or someone else with amazing talent. Stop it. Appreciate their work, not them. They are not your friends and family.
This meme has many alts. I went with Withered Wojak (Void Wojak), bc Doomer and Face Bleeding Wojak make me uncomfy.
26. “That’s Not Her Name”
At my own wedding, I planned to introduce Mer and a friend to see if they had hookup chemistry. Before I got to it, another lady friend swooped in and caught his attention. But this isn’t about my many single friends who are perfect partners for the right person but never make the first move, or how making the first move is the way to getting seconds.
When I caught up with Mer, I mentioned the incident. Her response was, “It’s for the best. He was talking to our friend and kept calling her Rihanna.”
Our friend is definitely not named Rihanna. I’m pretty sure only Rihanna is named Rihanna.
Getting someone’s name wrong is an ick, but getting it super wrong is a super ick. Like the speech-impediment ick of Volume 1, there are qualifiers. Yeah, yeah, yeah, you can mishear someone. But if you heard “Rihanna” (or “Beyonce”) you should ask, “Wait, did you say your name is Rihanna?”
27. Only has plastic utensils
In questioning what in the actual fuck the alternative is to stirring coffee with a little spoon, it came up that it’s a serious ick if someone only has plastic utensils. I would assume that person just moved, absolutely never cooks, and has mommy issues. All of the above. Two out of three, and they probably have at least one set of cutlery they stole from a Chili’s or school cafeteria.
This goes back to, “If you’re over 25, get your shit together.”
If you’re an adult and don’t take care of your apartment, it’s a red flag for dating. It’s a guarantee you’re a hookup at best, not meet-the-parents material. And while red flags aren’t icks, having only plastic utensils is so specific, I’m counting it.
Unless you’re living más and “every night is taco night” at your house, using plastic cutlery might be a sign to deactivate your social media and focus on finding a first, second, or third job to get your life in order.
the reveal
So the dating tip of this issue is for men who don’t know better: Take care of your apartment/home. Clean it. Frame pictures. I’m not going to tell you to get a bed frame, because if it weren’t for my wife and wanting storage space under the bed, I would have a mattress on the floor myself.
I can get even more general, because these conversations often turn to finances. Debt, no savings, overspending, taking out loans to go on vacation or have fun... ick. It’s a wonder I got married based on all that, but I guess that gives hope to my fellow financially illiterate bros who 100% should have a conservator.
Usually, people who are unemployed, buried in debt, and financially irresponsible are left in the hookup category, not the long-term category. Turns out there’s nothing wrong with having a good career and dating models thanks to it.